Fort Regent redevelopment: Jersey urged to protect public interests in potential private-sector deal

Jersey's government has been warned to take care when involving private investors in the future redevelopment of Fort Regent, with a former council leader cautioning ministers against allowing the public purse to lose out.
Gerald Vernon-Jackson, former leader of Portsmouth City Council, said the island needed to ensure private developers offered value for money while recognising that commercial companies would expect to make a profit.
His comments come after ministers revealed that private-sector investors could be invited to help transform Fort Regent, following a significant increase in the projected cost of the project.
The States-owned Jersey Development Company has so far been responsible for overseeing the redevelopment. However, while essential initial works will continue, the wider plans for the site are now being reconsidered.
A £43m loan will still fund asbestos removal and repairs to the roof of the currently closed leisure centre. However, the overall redevelopment costs have risen beyond the original £110m estimate, prompting officials to review how the remainder of the project should be delivered.
The scheme had originally been expected to finish by 2029, but there is now uncertainty over when the work could be completed.
Lessons from Portsmouth's waterfront development
Vernon-Jackson was speaking about the experiences of Portsmouth's Gunwharf Quays, a former military site at Portsmouth Harbour which was transformed through a partnership between the public and private sectors.
The historic site closed in the mid-1990s before being redeveloped into a major mixed-use destination featuring residential properties, the Spinnaker Tower and an outlet shopping centre, alongside restaurants, bars and leisure attractions.
Asked what Jersey could learn from the Portsmouth project, Vernon-Jackson said ministers should first establish a comprehensive master plan for the entire Fort Regent site.
He warned against approaching the redevelopment through a series of disconnected projects.
"Don't do it bit by bit by bit," he said.
He explained that having an overall vision would allow planners to understand how individual developments could contribute to the site's wider purpose.
Vernon-Jackson also stressed the importance of protecting public interests when negotiating with commercial developers.
"You've got to make sure that the private sector don't rip off the public sector, but also they're putting their money in at risk, and you need to recognise that private sector companies are there to make a profit," he said.
He added that businesses would be unlikely to invest if there was no realistic opportunity to generate a return.
Historic buildings and development compromises
Fort Regent, a substantial Grade I listed Napoleonic fort overlooking St Helier, has previously been earmarked for an ambitious transformation.
Earlier proposals included a 2,500-seat theatre, a 12-lane bowling alley, a six-screen cinema and new food and drink facilities.
The future of the building's roof has also been a major consideration. Plans submitted earlier this year proposed refurbishing the existing Grade II listed roof to restore its original 1970s appearance.
Reflecting on Gunwharf Quays, Vernon-Jackson acknowledged that the Portsmouth development had involved difficult decisions about the site's historic character.
He said a number of historic buildings had been demolished, a decision that some people continued to regret.
However, he believed the overall benefits of the redevelopment had outweighed the losses.
"The benefits of developing Gunwharf far outweigh the things that we lost," he said.
Ministers to review plans in 2027
Jersey's ministers are expected to consider the future direction of Fort Regent in 2027.
In the meantime, officials will continue assessing the costs of essential repairs while exploring whether there is sufficient commercial interest to attract private investment.
The change in approach has attracted criticism from hospitality industry representatives, who said they were "deeply disappointed, though sadly not surprised" by the decision to put the wider redevelopment plans on hold.
The challenge for the government will be to find a financially sustainable way to bring Fort Regent back into use while protecting one of the island's most significant historic landmarks.


